Tuesday, July 16, 2013

Apologies for the brief hiatus

Friends, Romans, Countrypeople--

I must apologize for what is becoming a short break from the blog.  I am currently in Orlando, Florida, attending my denomination's biannual General Assembly, and thought I originally anticipated being able to maintain a presence here on the blog during this week, I am having to balance doing some long-distance ministry with a family at FCC back in Longview, and they come first.

I realize that A LOT has happened in our crazy little world over the last few days, but these circumstances are dictating me to put the blog on the proverbial back burner for now.  However, I plan on being back in action here in a few days.

I appreciate your patience, and I hope y'all had a happy Bastille Day this past weekend!

(Because, hey, why not give a shout-out to Bastille Day?)

Yours in Christ,
Eric

Thursday, July 11, 2013

An Open Letter to the Pro-Life Movement (Especially in Texas)

(I know that especially compared to my last post, this one probably feels like a sharp turn into hardass-ville.  A friend and mentor from my college years (whom I have written for frequently in the past) invited me to write about the recent reproductive legislation in Texas (and Wisconsin) from a progressive Christian perspective, which I was more than willing to do.  I do consider abortion to be one of the issues I am the most moderate on, and I wrestle and struggle with my feelings about it often.  I hope that dilemma comes through to you in this piece, which was originally published here. -E.A.)

Hi.  You likely have no idea who I am, and that’s fine.  I will simply say that I am just like you, really.  I share your deep belief in God as revealed through Jesus Christ, and I actively seek to do God’s will in my life and my work as a Christian pastor.  I believe in the inherent dignity and sacredness of life, and because of that, I oppose the death penalty and adhere to a very narrow interpretation of just war theory.

In other words, I am exactly the sort of person you should theoretically be able to persuade, to get on your side, to believe that abortion in all or most circumstances should be illegal, because the theological foundation is already there.

But instead, I honestly find myself repulsed by what your state legislatures are doing in your name, and believe me, it isn’t because I somehow skipped over Psalm 139 and what it says about being knitted in my mother’s womb, of being fearfully and wonderfully made by God.

It’s because I have read the entire Bible too, and I worry that in what your leaders are doing, they (and you who voted for them) have skipped over another part of Scripture: Exodus 20:16.

You shall not bear false testimony.

Yep, one of the Big Ten.  Commandments, that is.

For instance, if you take Scripture—and its commandment for truth-telling—so seriously, then why do you tolerate the use of pseudo-science to deceive women, like telling them that abortions somehow cause breast cancer, or by voting for candidates who claim that women’s bodies can somehow magically shut-down a rape-induced pregnancy?

If you take Scripture—and its commandment for truth-telling—so seriously, then why do you condone your political leaders claiming that they want to shut down womens’ health clinics for the sake of womens’ health, as opposed to the sake of limiting access to abortion?

If you take Scripture—and its commandment for truth-telling—so seriously, then why do you try to downplay the statistical reality that universal access to contraception is empirically proven to reduce the frequency of abortions?

If you take Scripture—and its commandment for truth-telling—so seriously, then why do you allow your leaders to actively shut down the voices of women (and their monopoly on the direct experience of child-bearing) to the point that Texas state senator Leticia Van de Putte has to ask what a woman has to do to be recognized in a debate about her womb?

I could go on and on.

See, this is what I don’t get about the pro-life movement, even if I sympathize tremendously with your end goal of dramatically reducing the number of abortions.  You are letting that end goal justify your means…which, in this case, is a combination of fakery and deception.  You are pursuing an ostensibly Christian goal through means that are not Christian in the slightest.

To be sure, Wendy Davis is a hero to millions of Americans right now (and a villain to others).  But in following this saga, I found myself identifying with another female Texas state senator during Sen. Davis’ epic filibuster as well: Sen. Judith Zaffirini, who, despite her pro-life credentials, actively opposed SB5 because it would limit access to women’s health care.  And really, the word “despite” is inappropriate in that previous sentence.  I have to think Sen. Zaffirini opposed SB5 precisely because she was pro-life: life doesn’t just come from the womb, it continues outside the womb, and limiting access to care that upholds life outside the womb just does not seem to be on your leaders’ agenda at the moment.

And that might well be because of their beliefs about God and Scripture.  Perhaps sacrificing a woman’s well-being at the altar of protecting the unborn is just part and parcel of a Biblically-oriented politics.  After all, Scripture also says that a rape victim must marry her rapist (Deuteronomy 22:28-29), and that a wife being unwilling to be paraded around by her husband in front of his drunken friends is enough grounds for divorce (Esther 1:8-22).  For all I know, God actually approves of this use of half-truths and pseudo-science and denial of the realities of women’s health for the sake of preventing more abortions.

But I doubt it.  Because my own reading and study of Scripture tells me that God, too, is pro-life: for women as well as men, the born as well as the unborn.  And I have to think that more abortions would be prevented if we simply told the truth: about the science of pregnancy as well as of how to prevent it, and about how women’s health is a crucial and necessary component to an authentically pro-life religious ethos.

Thanks for reading.

Yours in Christ,
Eric

Tuesday, July 9, 2013

Entertaining Angels Unawares

(I have sat on this particular blog post for several weeks now, trying to convince myself that I am not crazy.  But I cannot get out of my head the notion that this might have been a God experience.  I figured I will just tell you, and let the chips fall as they may. -E.A.)

I could hear the popping sound as clear as day even amid the noise of the scrimmage game going on as my right ankle buckled and I collapsed to the ground.

At first, it felt like a run-of-the-mill ankle sprain--something that, over the course of twenty-some years of playing organized and pickup soccer, I am reasonably accustomed to suffering and subsequently DIY treating.  But the pain lingered higher up my ankle, in the area where my Achilles tendon attaches to my leg.

It wasn't a full tear of my right Achilles--which is one of the toughest of all athletic injuries to recover from.  I knew that it wasn't a full tear, and after talking to Carrie, she confirmed that my foot and ankle would be in much worse shape if that had been the case--but the more I noticed the location of the pain and recalled the popping noise, the more I was sure I had made at least a small rupture in the tendon.  So I went about my usual DIY treatment regimen: ice, elevation, compresses, etc.  I kept my right foot in a brace for a couple of weeks before flying down to Berkeley, California in mid-June to serve as a groomsman at my seminary roommate's wedding.

And the wedding was beautiful--it took place in the botanical gardens in Berkeley's Tilden Park.  But the specific spot of the outdoor wedding was on a lawn that sloped downward, and as such, trying to balance my stocky, 6'3" frame on an unsteady Achilles tendon proved to be an intense exercise in pain exacerbation.

A funny thing happened, though, on the plane ride back to Portland that I took that night: a mother and her four-year-old daughter sat next to me on the plane, and for the most part, it was a rather uneventful ride.  The girl was a fantastic traveler, and despite the constant dull throbbing I felt in my foot, I even managed the impossible: falling asleep on a plane with a little kid sitting right next to you.

But as we were beginning our descent, she looked over to stare out the window over the green Portland landscape as the plane slowly descended, and she finally became interested in this big bald fellow she had been sharing a plane ride with for the past two hours.  Her eyes getting big, she pointed at me and squealed, "YOU HAVE NO HAIR!!"

All I could do was laugh.  Her mother was embarrassed, I think, but I could not have cared less--I am perfectly fine being completely bald.

But it was enough for this little girl and me to chatter up a storm for the short remainder of the flight, and as I got up to set my bags on my shoulder, we waved goodbye to each other.

Then I started walking.

And I noticed that I was walking completely pain-free for the first time in weeks.

It wasn't a fluke, either--within three days, I was able to complete a 5K on the elliptical, and within another three weeks, I had returned to my normal level of fitness: 4 miles at a resistance of 10 or 11.  I have not only stayed pain-free, I have recovered.

And all I could think about afterwards was that verse from Hebrews 13: do not forget to entertain strangers, for in doing so, some have unknowingly entertained angels.

And I'm not saying that my Achilles would still be hurting if I hadn't talked and laughed with this little girl.  But the difference in how it felt was so stark, it was like night and day.  I have to think something happened.

And I realize that millions of other people seek miracles of healing and never find them.  Which is what really keeps me from indulging in enough hubris to be certain that that's what this was.  It is hard for me to say that I have had a miracle when so many other people need healing much more urgently than I do.  There is something in humility and humbleness that I feel like should keep me from claiming that.

But...for weeks of searing pain being taken away, I am immensely grateful.

For having the gift of my mobility return to me, I am very grateful.

And no matter which way you cut it, I know that I have God to thank for my health and my wholeness.

And so I pray that I might continue to entertain angels unawares.

Yours in Christ,
Eric

Sunday, July 7, 2013

This Week's Sermon: "Before the Bethlehem Star"

Numbers 9:15-23

15 On the day the dwelling was erected, the cloud covered the dwelling, the covenant tent. At night until morning, the cloud appeared with lightning over the dwelling. 16 It was always there. The cloud covered it by day,[d] appearing with lightning at night. 17 Whenever the cloud ascended from the tent, the Israelites would march. And the Israelites would camp wherever the cloud settled. 18 At the Lord’s command, the Israelites would march, and at the Lord’s command they would camp. As long as the cloud settled on the dwelling, they would camp. 19 When the cloud lingered on the meeting tent for many days, the Israelites would observe the Lord’s direction and they wouldn’t march. 20 Sometimes the cloud would be over the dwelling for a number of days, so they would camp at the Lord’s command, marching again only at the Lord’s command. 21 Sometimes the cloud would settle only overnight, and they would march when the cloud ascended in the morning. Whether it was day or night, they would march when the cloud ascended. 22 Whether it was two days, or a month, or a long time, the Israelites would camp so long as the cloud lingered on the dwelling and settled on it. They wouldn’t march. But when it ascended, they would march. 23 They camped at the Lord’s command and they marched at the Lord’s command. They followed the Lord’s direction according to the Lord’s command through Moses. (CEB)


“Behold a New Thing: The Tribal Church,” Week Six

It could not have been more painful.  She had been working on her car’s brakes when suddenly, the car’s jack buckled, and the entire thing came crashing down on her foot.  After her doctors assessed the nerve damage to her foot, she asked them to amputate her leg below the knee.

Yet, thus began a new calling for her.  Her day job, amazingly, enough, was as an occupational therapist for paraplegic persons at Washington University in St. Louis, and she put all of her professional skills and ingenuity to work on her recovery, and on her very public attempts to reassure others who had had recent amputations.  This work culminated recently in her posting a time-lapse video to Youtube of her building a prosthesis with Lego bricks from her childhood.

The LegoLeg, as she called it, was not functional enough to walk in, but she is able to stand and put weight on it.  Her new goal is to build a LegoLeg that she can walk in.  And from her home in St. Louis, she has begun to move the hearts of thousands of people, simply because she found a brand new use for a childhood toy: to stand instead of sit, and to one day walk instead of not.

We tell ourselves churches must look a certain way and beat ourselves up when they don’t.  But the church is what I imagine a child must be like—as Tina Fey puts it in her memoir Bossypants, yes, you can teach a child manners and dress her up in embarrassing little sailor outfits, but at some point, that child is going to be whatever she is going to be (and, ironically or no, that very line reflects the wonder and splendor of the divine name itself from Exodus 3: I Am Who I Am).

And that’s kind of what it is like for us, you know?  Lots of people would say they know what we should look like—they want to tell us which little sailor outfits to dress up in—but at some point, this church is going to be whatever this church is.  And after being here as your pastor for nearly two years, I have found the closest thing possible to describing what this church is, and what we can become: a so-called tribal church, ministering to a missing generation of believers.

This term comes from a 2007 book of the same name by Carol Howard Merritt, a Generation X evangelically-raised Presbyterian pastor and author.  And we will be basing this new six-week sermon series on this book, as we look at what exactly a tribal church is, and what it can truly do.  We have now spent five weeks on this book and on this sermon series, and we have arrived at the final installment, whose theme is “nurturing spiritual community.”  Carol writes in this chapter:

The aging congregation in Rhode Island that I pastored had a steady stream of dying members.  Each time I buried someone, I soon got another call about a dear friend in intensive care, or a kind man who had just passed quickly and quietly.  Intense waves of grief washed over the family members, and as I sat with the loved ones, I longed to have someone sit with me.

In the midst of this, I had an early miscarriage.  I felt life and hope drain out of me, but I still didn’t have the support that pastors need in their own periods of sadness, denial, and bargaining.  I said goodbye to a couple of close friends who moved away, and could not find much strength to fill the void…

It was a dark year in my life, and I stumbled and tripped all the way through it.  I didn’t know how to ask for help, and when I did, I had the terrible feeling that somehow needing it was the wrong thing.  I figured that other pastors must have gone through the same things, but talking to others in the denomination about my weaknesses made me feel…well, weak.

Carol writes these words in a chapter about her discovery of moving prayer—literally, praying while moving.  And for her, it is one significant way in which spirituality gets nurtured.  And it makes sense to me on a personal and religious level as well—personal because I’m this fidgety young thing who doesn’t always sit still, and religious because of stories like this from Numbers.

Numbers might just be the most underrated book in the Bible.  It is sandwiched between two legal masterpieces—Leviticus and Deuteronomy—and is known primarily for documenting the first-ever census of the Israelites.  Which, I mean, is cool and everything, but it doesn’t really hold a candle to a plague of locusts, you know?  Numbers is so underrated that I’m willing to bet that its most famous passage is something most of you know, but had no idea that it came from Numbers: it’s the prayer “May the Lord bless you and keep you, may the Lord deal kindly and graciously to you, may the Lord make His face to shine upon you and give you peace.”  It’s Numbers 6, but I didn’t know that until I took an Old Testament class in college.

But anyways, Numbers 9.  Everything between here and Exodus 20, when Moses is given the Ten Commandments—so, the second half of Exodus, all of Leviticus, and the first nine chapters of Numbers—all of it takes place at Sinai.  It’s a pretty big intermission on the journey to the Promised Land, and you can imagine that after such a lengthy—and meaningful—break, that setting back out on the trail again wasn’t the easiest thing to get up and go do.  You lose inertia and momentum, and that ups the degree of difficulty substantially.

And so in Numbers 9 (the more I say it, will anyone start to get that Beatles song, “Revolution Number Nine” stuck in their head?), God intervenes to dial that degree of difficulty back down.  He manifests a supernatural phenomenon to guide the movement of the Israelite camp—a cloud by day, and fire by night.  And this supernatural cloud and fire guides the Israelites from point to point by settling at wherever they are to encamp for the night, and staying there until God tells the Israelites to break camp again, at which point it would go on ahead to the next point. 

Now, I’m not sure exactly how well this divine GPS navigation system worked—after all, it took the Israelites forty years to traverse a patch of land that Google Maps says should take you only about five hours to drive across (yes, I actually looked up how long it takes to drive from Cairo to Ramah.  Now you have some idea of how your pastor spends his day of sermon prep).  Yet still, it was, and is, miraculous nonetheless, God-Garmin or not.

And compared to the Sinai narrative—where all of this legal code is handed down to Moses and the Israelites basically in one place and in one fell swoop—this is a gradual revelation of God’s presence.  In other words, God works both ways.  God can overwhelm us in a singular instance of wonder and splendor, and God can also guide us bit by bit and piece by piece.

Because this is not the only time in Scripture when God uses supernatural phenomena to guide people somewhere.  It is how, in Matthew’s Gospel, He uses the Bethlehem star to guide the Magi to the birthplace of Jesus in Bethlehem.  It’s the exact same sort of thing—God sends a divine manifestation that moves and guides a people to a promised destination.  For Moses and the Israelites, it is the land that they shall call home.  For the Magi—and for us—it is to the Christ child whom we shall call Savior.  In both instances, God uses the gradual journey to lead us to something far greater than ourselves.  In other words…God works both ways.

Which means that the church must work both ways as well.  I worry that far too often, we treat bringing someone into the church, or to the point that they want to be in right relationship with God through Jesus Christ, as the finish line, the objective, the target to aim for.  The evangelist Billy Sunday once famously said that the best thing that could happen to someone is to die immediately after converting to Christianity, because they had just achieved all they needed to.

And that can’t be how a tribal church operates.  A tribal church isn’t just there for the mountaintop moments, those fleeting instances where God’s grace and presence overwhelms us to the point of being called to Christianity.  A tribal church must be there for all the moments that come after as well.  A church that is only in it for the born-again experience is acting like a fair-weather friend: there for when things are at their best.  No, a church must be more than that.

And that is the best way I can come up with, after six weeks of preaching on this, to define what a tribal church looks like to me.  I know many of you have asked, and this is the best answer I can give: a tribal church creates a tribe around a common cause and belief—the existence of God as taught and embodied by Jesus—and then cares for that tribe in sometimes the most basic of ways, but ways in which its members can be cared for in no other way, and that is why I think most tribal churches are intergenerational, theologically diverse, and increasingly creative.

A young woman who had just endured an utterly painful, life-and-limb-altering experience had elected to nurture a community around a common cause through the internet, and the result was, well, a new prosthetic made of old childhood toys.  And the attention it received after going viral contributed to the building and growing of another community, an online tribe of people.

Behold a new thing, indeed.

For, just as God creates in us a new thing when we finally say “Yes!” to His call, so too do we then, in turn, create in others new things as well.  It’s a divine chain reaction, a God-inspired ripple effect that affects not just us, but our entire tribe.  For just as there was no way of knowing for most of the Israelites just exactly what God had in store for them after the Exodus out of Egypt, so too are we allowed to be amazed and inspired anew at how God guides our spirituality in the desert as well as on the mountaintop, and on the path as well as at the destination.

Thanks be to God.  Amen.

Rev. Eric Atcheson
Longview, Washington
July 7, 2013

Wednesday, July 3, 2013

Some Thoughts on What De Tocqueville Called "The American Experiment"

(I realize that this post is being written against the backdrop of a military coup in Egypt, but this post was originally planned as an Independence Day reflection.  Nevertheless, I think both angles are applicable here. -E.A.)

When Alexis de Tocqueville wrote his two-volume magnum opus, "On Democracy in America," his purpose was to analyze why our representative democracy model of governance was succeeding here, whereas similar models were not over in Europe, especially in de Tocqueville's native France.  By and large, it is a positive portrayal of how our nation works--and keep in mind, this was an analysis written while we still had institutional slavery and were violently oppressing vast populations of American Indians.

In other words, we have come a long way.

But at least two of de Tocqueville's observations about our democracy remain extraordinarily true in my experience: first, that a democracy, if left unchecked, can devolve into a "soft despotism" that is more widely labeled today as a tyranny of the majority--that is, the majority gets what it wants at the expense of the minority's rights.  And second, that religious life here is so strong precisely because of, and not in spite of, the Establishment Clause of the First Amendment, guaranteeing separation from church and state.  If these two sound unrelated at the outset, I promise you that they are, in fact, very much intertwined.

Because we live in a nation far different than the Biblical Israel in which Christianity was founded--different in terms of language, culture, geography, social ethics--the whole nine yards.  Including, it must be noted, majority religion.

Christianity was not founded as a majority religion, nor was it a majority religion ANYWHERE for the first 300ish years of its existence, until Constantine the Great rolled along and instituted it as the Roman state religion.

And I have to think that somewhere in the midst of the past 1,700 or so years, we Western Christians have forgotten what it is like to be the minority.  There are nations today in which Christians are severely persecuted--Egypt being one of them--but the United States is currently not such a nation (though our history includes substantial persecution of Roman Catholics and Mormons).

It's truly an irony from my perspective: the American Christian church bemoans its loss of status, yet even as recently as 2008, it was getting same-sex marriage bans passed in states across the country, even in more left-leaning states such as Oregon and California.

But because of the setbacks dealt recently towards "traditional marriage" proponents--like the recent Supreme Court rulings striking down DOMA and Prop 8--I keep hearing this refrain that Christians are being persecuted here.

And that does not pass the proverbial smell test to me, because when we do things like trying to uphold DOMA, we are engaging in a form of that "soft despotism" that de Tocqueville writes about.  We are enabling the majority to have its way at the expense of a minority's rights.

Repealing laws that engage in that isn't persecution--it is a balancing of the scales.

And it is something that we have been good at in the past, and something we must continually strive to improve at.  Because if we are going to say that America really is the place where anyone can get a fair shake, that we are the last true meritocracy, that we, to paraphrase Martin Luther King Jr., judge on the content of character, then we need to take seriously the praise that a French political philosopher doled out in heaps to our model of governance nearly 180 years ago.

We can be the newest and greatest version of the experiment of democracy that began all the way in ancient Greece.

But we have to want it.

And part of wanting it is recognizing that American Christianity is a religion, not a hegemon.

I do not expect such recognition to be easy, but it will not make the sky fall, and the nation we share will be better for us having done so.

I wish all of you a happy and safe Fourth!

Yours in Christ,
Eric

Tuesday, July 2, 2013

July 2013's Newsletter Column + Preaching Schedule

Letters from the Soul, July 2013

"Belonging to a Tribe"


I have truly enjoyed this past “The Tribal Church” sermon series with all of you, and I hope you have found it as enriching as I have! Working on this series has made me consider what it means to be a part of a tribal church, and I do think that part of being in a tribe means that not everyone is necessarily a member. But—church is such a tribe where everyone has the potential to become a member! So, how do we go about offering a welcome to strangers in our strange land who are interested in the little tribe we have going here on the corner of Kessler and 20th? 


The first thing we can do is also the most important—we can share with our friends and loved ones how much our faith and our church mean to us! This isn’t the same thing as going up to someone and giving them the “turn or burn” spiel, this is sharing with other people a source of God’s love for you in your life! 

There are also a great many other things to welcome newcomers to our little tribe (such as inviting them to stay for our hospitality hour), but I think the most important thing we can do is this: don’t assume anything! Remember, brand-new guests may not know that they are sitting in your favorite pew, or that there is nursery care available if they choose to use it. The gift of your patience and compassion means a great deal to many people, perhaps more than you might realize! 

So as we go about being this tribal church that cares for one another, I invite you to ask yourself: how can you use your God-given gifts to roll out the proverbial welcome mat for someone who might feel foreign in our spiritual home?

Yours in Christ,
Eric

July 2013: Upcoming Sermons

July 7 (continuation of current "Tribal Church" sermon series): "Before the Bethlehem Star," Numbers 9:15-23

July 14 and 21: Guest preachers

July 28 (new sermon series, "The Gospel Gone Viral"): "You've Got Mail," Philemon 1-3

Monday, July 1, 2013

This Week's Sermon: "The Wife of Lappidoth"

Judges 4:1-10

After Ehud had died, the Israelites again did things that the Lord saw as evil. 2 So the Lord gave them over to King Jabin of Canaan, who reigned in Hazor. The commander of his army was Sisera, and he was stationed in Harosheth-ha-goiim. 3 The Israelites cried out to the Lord because Sisera[a] had nine hundred iron chariots and had oppressed the Israelites cruelly for twenty years. 4 Now Deborah, a prophet, the wife of Lappidoth,[b] was a leader of Israel at that time. 5 She would sit under Deborah’s palm tree between Ramah and Bethel in the Ephraim highlands, and the Israelites would come to her to settle disputes. 6 She sent word to Barak, Abinoam’s son, from Kedesh in Naphtali and said to him, “Hasn’t the Lord, Israel’s God, issued you a command? ‘Go and assemble at Mount Tabor, taking ten thousand men from the people of Naphtali and Zebulun with you. 7 I’ll lure Sisera, the commander of Jabin’s army, to assemble with his chariots and troops against you at the Kishon River, and then I’ll help you overpower him.’” 8 Barak replied to her, “If you’ll go with me, I’ll go; but if not, I won’t go.” 9 Deborah answered, “I’ll definitely go with you. However, the path you’re taking won’t bring honor to you, because the Lord will hand over Sisera to a woman.” Then Deborah got up and went with Barak to Kedesh. 10 He summoned Zebulun and Naphtali to Kedesh, and ten thousand men marched out behind him. Deborah marched out with him too. (CEB)



“Behold a New Thing: The Tribal Church,” Week Five

The young Presbyterian pastor was “teaching the last confirmation class at my house.  The thirteen-year-olds munched on Papa John’s pizza as we discussed the Trinity, how to pray, and church polity.  I didn’t go into a full description of the constitution of the church, just the basic things that they needed to know, like the importance of lay people in our church government.  I explained that “Presbyterian” comes from the Greek word “presbvterios,” which means “elder.”

“Oh!” exclaimed (one of the students), who’d stopped chewing her pepperoni and wore one of those faces that every teacher longs for, that one which indicated that she finally got it.  “So that’s why everyone at the church is so old!”  (The pastor’s) smile fell.  Teenagers have an amazing knack for truth telling.

We tell ourselves churches must look a certain way and beat ourselves up when they don’t.  But the church is what I imagine a child must be like—as Tina Fey puts it in her memoir Bossypants, yes, you can teach a child manners and dress her up in embarrassing little sailor outfits, but at some point, that child is going to be whatever she is going to be (and, ironically or no, that very line reflects the wonder and splendor of the divine name itself from Exodus 3: I Am Who I Am).

And that’s kind of what it is like for us, you know?  Lots of people would say they know what we should look like—they want to tell us which little sailor outfits to dress up in—but at some point, this church is going to be whatever this church is.  And after being here as your pastor for nearly two years, I have found the closest thing possible to describing what this church is, and what we can become: a so-called tribal church, ministering to a missing generation of believers.

This term comes from a 2007 book of the same name by Carol Howard Merritt, a Generation X evangelically-raised Presbyterian pastor and author.  And we will be basing this new six-week sermon series on this book, as we look at what exactly a tribal church is, and what it can truly do.  We kicked off the series by examining one of the initial tenets of the book: “fostering intergenerational relationships,” followed by “encouraging economic understanding” and “cultivating unambiguous inclusion.”  Last week had the theme of “discovering affirming traditions,” and this week’s theme is “promoting shared leadership.”  Carol writes in this chapter:

Many congregations long for intergenerational growth.  Yet once it happens, they are rarely prepared for the stress that can also develop.  Often, churches do not realize that inviting young members into their congregation means allowing them to have some weight in decisions, and sharing power can be the largest obstacle in the way of ministering with young adults.  And, as Ethan Watters notes, “Things that change precipitously from one generation to the next are usually greeted by the older generation as the death of everything good and right.”  And all too often, younger generations find themselves…trying to navigate through change in the middle of a heated battle for the summit of some sand hill.  But no one likes to fight on his volunteer time.  So, young people simply end up walking downhill and resume wandering in another direction.

The story I told at the very beginning of this sermon *also* comes from this chapter, because, quite frankly, it was hard to top, for both truth-telling and for humor.

Because it is true.  Sometimes, we expect our leaders to look a certain way.  We want our church elders to be “elderly,” which means our deacons should be... “deaconly?”  Or, we want our presidents to look “presidential,” which as far as I can tell means being somewhat tall and having fantastic hair.  We want our beauty queens to be long-haired and elegant and without an ounce of body fat.  And we want our churches to, well, look like us.  If we walk into a church with lots of young people, and we are a young person, we are supposed to react like its catnip.

But that’s not us, here at FCC.  And I don’t think that’s Biblical Israel, either, under the judges.

In a manner, Biblical Israel had a democracy of sorts during the time of the Judges—Israel itself was not a formal nation, more a confederation of the twelve tribes, and whenever a threat arose—usually one of war, and in this case, war against the foreign ruler Jabin, who had oppressed Israel for twenty years—that threatened the interests of all twelve tribes, the Israelites would all rally behind a collective leader who was called a judge, and would then rule for many years, until a new set of circumstances dictated the need of a new judge.  It wasn’t a formal democracy, but it certainly was closer to a meritocracy than the absolute monarchy that followed.

And I feel secure in saying that precisely because of Deborah.  We live in a country with full rights for women, and we are still waiting for our first female president, but Biblical Israel, with some awfully draconian laws concerning women—especially regarding marriage—has now a female judge, whom we know only as the wife of some dude named Lappidoth: Deborah.

Deborah was not like the kings—and many of the judges—for a simple reason: she ruled collaboratively.  In this case, she judged Israel—ruling on disputes, dispensing counsel, and the like—but in military matters, she led alongside an Israelite man named Barak…but if you read through their interactions in this passage—especially Barak’s declaration of “I’ll only go if you go” in verse 8, it’s kind of clear who wears the pants in this relationship, and who irons them.

In other words, even with a man leading beside her, Deborah’s judgeship over Israel breaks the norm.  And that is what we must be doing in the church today.  We must break the norm. Because, honestly, being in the norm is what can sometimes get us into trouble.  If we get complacent with where we are, and too comfortable in what we are doing here, our spirituality is liable to atrophy—to grow weaker from disuse.

And that is a difficult thing to admit, because it implies that all of us—myself included—are NEVER done growing as Christians.  There are always growing edges, always learning curves, always some other dimension to this thing we call being a Christian.

But I worry that we are frightened by those growing edges and those learning curves to the point of active resistance—that we become, as Carol noted, like the generation who sees new things happening and bemoans the downfall of everything good and right.  In fact, I am willing to bet that there were some Israelites—maybe even quite a few—who saw the reality of having a female judge lead them and shook their fists at the way things had become!

And I think the church—and Christians—can be particularly prone to that.  We elevate previous incarnations of the church, stretching all the way back to Acts of the Apostles, to almost mythical status, and suddenly whatever the church we have now does, it cannot ever quite measure up.  The doctrine has become too loose.  The music has become too sacreligious.  The preacher has become too young.  (Ruh-roh!)

But promoting shared leadership means being able and willing to accept some leadership from unlikely sources.  And I think we have done that in a big way here already, not only by saying to ourselves, “Hey, there’s this 25-year-old pastor in Berkeley, let’s pluck him out of there and make him ours even though he’s just a pipsqueak,” but also by allowing new leadership to ascend to our Board of Directors and to our elders.  Out of all the themes presented in the Tribal Church book, this is one where we are, at least on paper, probably ahead of the curve here.  With myself and Justin, we have two board participants under the age of 30.  Trust me, that is a rarity.

And I think that is a rarity because visitors to a church see things very differently from long-times members.  If you’ve been around the church a while—and some of you have heard me say this—you’re liable to view the church like, say, the Soviet planned economy in Cold War Russia: you are assigned a job that meets the pre-determined needs of the collective.  The church thinks it needs a 6am sunrise sing-a-long service?  You’d better be there with bells and whistles.  But the visitor or brand-new member is more apt to look at that and say, “Why?”  They’re the ones who would, at the risk of just killing this metaphor, get packed off to Siberia for dissent.  They questioned the pre-determined needs of the collective, and as a result, they weren’t welcome.  And you’d be amazed how often that happens in the church.  It’s astounding.

Promoting shared leadership, then, doesn’t just mean letting newcomers into our way of doing things, it is them letting us into their own deepest hopes and dreams for this wonderful thing that we call the Christian Church.  And that’s the way it should be, in the end, because we cannot always look for our leadership in the most expected of places.

If we did, Israel would have never called the wife of Lappidoth to be their judge and leader.

The Pharaoh of Egypt would never have called Joseph, an incarcerated slave, to be his governor.

God Himself would never have called Moses, an exiled murderer, to lead and liberate His people, nor would He have called David, a baby brother shepherd boy, to unite Israel as a nation.

And most importantly, the Son of God would never have come as a humble, itinerant carpenter.

Promoting—and thus also submitting to—this sort of leadership is rarely a straightforward, orderly affair.  We have tried to make it such, with formulaic prayers of salvation and memorized creeds, but the reality of godly leadership is such that it transcends our attempts to place it neatly and tidily into a box, for no other reason than that God Himself is so, so much bigger than that.

Thanks be to God.  Amen.

Rev. Eric Atcheson
Longview, Washington
June 30, 2013